Which of these do you prefer?

Option B. Looks a lot less cluttered, and we don't really need to know our breath level unless we're in danger of running out.

 

Definitely B. The more bars there are on the screen the more I tend to find myself staring at bars the whole time rather than staring at all the game's pretty arts

 

Option B looks cool
I like B
It might be not as pretty as a, but i feel like it's more informative than a
More simple than A

 

B for sure. Less GUI clutter is great, and the food bar fits great in the upper left w/ health.

 

Yeah, B is way better

 

B... Bars are awesome

 

Top is supposed to have a lot of stuff. This isn't a MOBA, so it's fine to have clear areas of the screen and irregularities.

~ockpii

EDIT: Eh, both are fine. I like the design of A.

 

B is more appealing IMO.

 

B makes a lot more sense. Looks better imo

 

Definitely B. The food bar seems to fit well under the health/energy bars, and a consistent piece of UI just seems out of place at the bottom of the screen.

 

B. I don't mind the food meter being there all the time. And less focus on the bars when they aren't in danger is a better way to go about it.

 

I like A.

 

I think they both look slightly confusing or at least they require to look at a lot of parts of the screen, that said to give honest feedback I should probably play first and see if I get used to it.

Option B seems better at least, it's coherent that the hunger bar is there and there's two neatly separated bars for the other things.

Have you considered the idea of not including them in the hud and maybe make them pop up at certain checkpoints, but still making them accessible in between those via inventory or other things?

EDIT: nevermind, apparently B partly has this, which makes it even better!

 

B for sure.

Or, option B rotated 90 degrees on a side of the screen.

 

I like where the breath bar is in A. Needs to be somewhere where you WILL see it. And you're already looking up top.

I'd support a hybridization where the breath bar is moved in B.

 

B. The less clutter the better.
(Or option C. No bars, just a numerical display that changes colour to reflect your heat levels. And the hunger/oxygen levels from option B.)

 

I like B, but put the GUI at the bottom of the screen to the top, So we can see all the bars in one place at any given time

 

B, absolutely. The food bar is very subtle and it's useful to be able to look at a single location to see a summary of your current status.

 

Offtopic: Look at that! Never thought I'd catch you in action .

I voted B, but I like A too. B seems more like the style it should be. A is what I want it to be .