Which of these do you prefer?

Where is option 3 with nothing at the bottom, and the last two things you have at the top near the hotbars??

 

I think I like B better. I like having the hunger bar by the character portrait. As for the other two bars, I'm not entirely sure what I prefer. The best thing would be to have several different UI placement options in a menu, but that's extra work, which you don't need right now.

 

Option B is very neat and easy to read. Option A is a little bit everywhere.

 

I don't know i live the overall feel of A i don't really have any other way of explaining why lol

 

i think B , but the guys that says the other option looks cool too
I smell BETA xD

 

I like B, but why do the bars need to be at the bottom? They could be at the top like the air bar in A.

 

i much prefer a
perhaps make it so you have a choice that would be great, just a suggestion
Edit: I've changed my mind even if i voted a, i still think a choice would be good

 

Out of the two, B is the best. It looks very collected, and flows nicely. I would swap the breath bar and food bar, and put the food bar under the health as it was in A. That is my preference.

 

Just add a hud options subsection and let us choose.

 

Why not make it so that you can hold a button and then pull your GUI around how you want it? Is that possible? That would open the possibility for everyone to create his own GUI layout should he not be happy with the standart one. And maybe make it snap to the borders of the screen if it comes near it.

 

Must admit, I do like them both. But since I have to choose from one of the two, I vote for B.

 

I like B more.

 

I want the temperature bar to look as it did before, the current one is just too simple.

 

B, although I'd rather the meters be at the top of the screen rather than at the bottom.

 

Simple's what they were going for.

 

How about you make a selectable icons?

 

I think it's a bit important to have the breath meter close to the center of the screen. Something I notice when I'm playing Terraria is that it's a bit impractical to navigate the underwater terrain while having to look up towards the corner of the screen all the time and keep track of my breath. I would prefer being able to look at my character and at the same time be able to pay attention to the breath meter.

I guess the same applies to the temperature meter if there are cases where you have to constantly pay attention to the temperature.
I think it's less important with the hunger, as that one will drain much slower.

 

B, the extra bar on the top is barely visible compared, I rather have the main screen free.

 

Have you considered non-bar approach, like for example in "Don't Starve" where you apply some "frost/ice" overlay around the screen and play warning sound after the body temperature parameter gets too low or pass certain thresholds?..