Which of these do you prefer?

I prefer B over A - it is definitely more clear are UI seems more consistent IMO.

On the other hand I'd move bars in B from bottom of the screen to top, like A's breathing bar. It would be best in my opinion .

 

B is brilliant.

 

Option B looks great.
As someone already wrote, hide the breath bar while it's not in use.

 

B, with the breath bar only appearing in water or in an environment without breathable air.

 

A.

 

Well i would pefer a way to pick from both. But I do like the look of both really well. A more then B

 

C, put the option to toggle between A and B?

 

B, no doubt... The less GUI, the better!

 

I like A. I prefer to have such information available to me at a glance. However, the difference isn't very big so I could live with either.

 

C. I like how it works now, with the bars only appearing when decreasing.

 

I like option A, except with a minor change. Put the Food/Temp bar between the hotbar and breath bar up top and you will have a UI that looks better than both options.

 

Whoever mystically revived this thread out of nowhere, amazing job man, best necro ever (is it though, or is on-topic posting still a necro? whats the rule here lol)