Bug/Issue PS4: Craft Master trophy bug

So I've been trying to obtain all the trophies and have been working on Craft Master. I made several chest, looked up to make sure I had every recipe (realized I'd missed Robin completely!), found ingredients to everything (even if I was sure I'd made it already), and got to work making one of everything.

After triple checking all my chests with the official list of craftable items I KNOW I've made them all....and still no trophy.

Is it a bug or was a new item added since the list was made?

(I'll reiterate here I'm using the downloaded version on PS4)