I had two quests running, "How to Win Friends" and "Jodi's Request". How to win friends requires me to give anyone a gift. Jodi's Request requires me to give her a cauliflower. I was excited that I grew a single cauliflower and I went to Jodi. Unfortunately it filled the "How to Win Friends" quest instead of "Jodi's Request". I think that because it is a specific request by Jodi, it should not be considered a "gift".