Game Won't Load for Specific Character

So I just started a new game file yesterday. Everything was going fine, no issues. Today, however, when I try to load my character save, this is what happens: The loading screen will appear, then the music cuts out and the entire program just exits out. I looked at so many forums and videos, but none seem to work for some reason.
I had created a new character file to see if maybe this will help. Oddly, the game loads perfectly fine for the second character, but continues to crash for the first. The files for the original character are still in tact and functional, so I have no idea why this is happening or what could be causing the problem for this character specifically. If anyone has any solutions, please let me know!